On Monday, the U.S. Department of Justice announced a powerful new effort to stop local practices that unfairly target poor people, trapping them in “cycles of poverty that can be nearly impossible to escape.” Courts across the country are requiring people arrested with minor misdemeanor charges—like driving with a suspended license—to pay fines before getting their day in court. If they can’t afford the fine, they are forced to wait behind bars until they can.
In a statement and letter, the DOJ shed light on what the agency calls a “bureaucratic cover charge for the right to seek justice,” but also another alarming practice: the use of for-profit companies to collect fines and manage probation.
On top of fines collected on behalf of courts, many private probation companies charge their own fees for things like drug testing and supervision. If people can’t pay these fees—which can be as high as the fines themselves—they can be sent back to jail.
In a letter on Monday, the U.S. DOJ shed light on the use of for-profit companies to collect fines and manage probation.
According to the DOJ, these companies have a “direct pecuniary interest in the management or outcome of a case.” And this interest is real. In October of last year, a private probation company left the state of Alabama after a non-profit legal organization, Equal Justice Under Law, filed lawsuits accusing them of using the threat of jail to collect high fees.
As we revealed earlier this year, probation is just one of the many areas of our criminal justice system where private companies profit. Companies perform familiar functions like prison operation and immigrant detention, but even GPS ankle monitoring and residential reentry.
In all of these areas, including probation, these companies profit more when more people are in the system.
The DOJ’s effort is a significant step in righting our criminal justice system, which too often relies on policing and incarceration to “heal” wounds inflicted by much deeper causes. It also highlights the role of the private corrections industry in making that system anything but just.
We’d love to hear from you. Send us an email: firstname.lastname@example.org.
Please sign up for our mailing list. You’ll get one privatization story (private prisons, infrastructure, education, and more) a week in your inbox.